A new secret shopper study published in JAMA Health Forum on October 16, 2026 puts hard numbers on issues related to mental health network adequacy and provider directories. The study, Mental Health Ghost Networks in Commercial Insurance Plans, tested the directories of the largest commercial carrier in each of five states and found that only about one out of eight single calls to a listed psychiatrist or psychologist resulted in an appointment.
For employers, this is not just an insurer problem. It is a legal compliance problem. The No Surprises Act (NSA) places provider directory obligations directly on group health plans, not just on insurers. The Department of Labor (DOL) has made inaccurate provider lists and mental health network adequacy explicit enforcement priorities. And the study arrives just weeks after DOL guidance signaling that the Employee Benefits Security Administration (EBSA) expects plans to take concrete steps on network adequacy.
Just as important, the study suggests that many employees are not getting the in-network mental health care their plans promise. Even when participants follow the plan’s directory, they frequently cannot reach a listed provider, get an appointment, or be seen in a reasonable time, which can leave them choosing between more costly out-of-network care and forgoing treatment altogether.
Below we summarize the findings of the JAMA study and outline what plan sponsors should be doing now.
What the Study Found
Researchers placed 5,822 calls between October 2025 and March 2026 to psychiatrists and psychologists listed in the online directories of the largest commercial carrier in Delaware, Montana, New Jersey, Rhode Island, and Virginia, using a simulated patient in a standard PPO plan with a nonemergency mental health condition. A call was considered “evaluable” in the following circumstances:
- The caller reached office staff and was able to verify appointment availability, network directory accuracy, and/or clinician capacity.
- The caller received a disconnection or out-of-service message. The study counted these calls as directory contact information errors.
A call was considered “non-evaluable” if it went unanswered or the caller encountered an automated system through which verification of network directory information was not possible.
Key findings include:
- Most calls never reached a person. 61.3% of calls were nonevaluable, most commonly because the caller reached only an answering machine or automated system (44.2% of all calls).
- Few evaluable calls led to care. Of the remaining evaluable calls, fewer than a quarter resulted in an appointment with the listed clinician, rising to 32.1% when alternate clinicians at the same number were included.
- Directory errors were the dominant barrier to network access. Directory inaccuracies affected more than half of evaluable calls. More than 10% of evaluable calls reached a disconnected or out-of-service number.
- Capacity was the second barrier. In over 20% of evaluable calls, the clinician was not accepting new patients or offering appointments.
- Waits and travel were significant. The mean wait for an appointment was 20.5 days. Mean travel time was 17.1 minutes overall but this increased to over half an hour for rural residents and to 41.8 minutes in Montana.
The authors caution that results may not generalize to smaller carriers, other plan types, or other states, and that callers made only a single attempt per listing, so persistent patients would likely do better. At the same time, they reason that because the largest carrier in each state typically has the broadest network and greatest administrative capacity, the problem among smaller and less resourced carriers is likely worse. Many self-insured employer plans access these same carrier networks and directories through administrative services arrangements, so plan sponsors should not assume these findings describe someone else’s plan.
Directory Accuracy Is a Plan Obligation Under the No Surprises Act
ERISA Section 720, added by the NSA, requires group health plans to provide an accurate provider directory to participants. While TPAs typically handle the requirements related to provider directories, group health plans must ensure these requirements are met. Under the NSA, group health plans must verify and update the provider directory information in its public database at least once every 90 days and establish a procedure to remove providers or facilities whose information the plan cannot verify within a period the plan specifies. Databases must be updated within two business days after receiving updated information from a provider.
Section 720(b) adds a financial backstop that employers should not overlook. If a participant receives care from an out-of-network provider after the plan’s directory, database, or response protocol indicated the provider was in network, the plan may not impose cost-sharing greater than the in-network amount and must apply the in-network deductible and out-of-pocket maximum. In other words, ghost listings can shift additional cost to the plan.
Provider directory requirements took effect January 1, 2022, yet the JAMA study highlights that failure to comply with these requirements continues to be a major issue for group health plans. As we noted in our January post, the DOL has specifically indicated that inaccurate provider directories as a barrier to mental health and substance use disorder benefits are included in its 2026 enforcement priorities. Plans should confirm provider directories are up to date and accurate, with controls to promptly correct inaccuracies and prevent inadvertent out-of-network charges due to directory errors.
Ghost Listings Also Distort Network Adequacy, a Top Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act (MHPAEA) Priority
The study’s most important implication for mental health parity compliance may be its observation that common network adequacy measures, such as clinician-to-enrollee ratios and time and distance standards, count every clinician who appears in a directory, regardless of whether the clinician can be reached, is accepting patients, or practices the listed specialty. If your TPA’s network adequacy reporting is based on its provider directory, the reporting may not actually reflect participants’ experience finding a mental health provider.
As discussed in our September post, EBSA’s recent Field Assistance Bulletin No. 2026-03 identifies network adequacy standards as one of three priority nonquantitative treatment limitation (NQTL) enforcement areas. EBSA’s compliance tool notes that differences in how plans monitor whether they have enough mental health/substance use disorder providers versus medical/surgical providers in each geographic area, as well as differences in measures taken to address identified gaps, will be considered enforcement red flags.
Furthermore, EBSA has previously run its own secret shopper surveys similar in design to the JAMA study, and, as reported in the 2024 MHPAEA Report to Congress, found results were consistently worse for mental health/substance use disorder providers than for medical/surgical providers. EBSA also cautioned that inaccurate provider directories can lead to misleading results about participants’ access to care. For example, an incorrect provider address can distort whether a plan meets the time and distance standards in a given zip code or geographic area, and a retired provider who is still listed in the directory can inflate clinician-to-enrollee ratios. Therefore, inaccurate provider directories could lead to an erroneous conclusion that a network is accurate and/or adequate.
Ensuring an accurate provider directory will allow plans to fully understand where they fall short, rather than relying on provider counts that may overstate the care actually available, and to take targeted steps (such as network gap exceptions, single-case agreements, and expanded telehealth) so that participants are not exposed to out-of-network costs because of an inadequate network.
Fiduciaries Have a Duty to Monitor Adequacy of TPA Networks
Plan fiduciaries frequently, and fairly, point out that they cannot create mental health clinicians where a shortage exists, and that a single employer has little leverage to force a national carrier to overhaul its network.
But the fiduciary standard is about process, not guaranteed outcomes, and lack of leverage to force immediate, broad-scale network improvements does not mean fiduciaries are relieved of the burden to continue to push for improvements and alternative solutions.
EBSA’s recent compliance tool emphasizes the fiduciary obligation of self-insured plans to prudently select and monitor service providers, including TPAs, managed behavioral health organizations, claims administrators, and network administrators, and the tool suggests smaller-scale approaches to addressing network gaps that may be more reasonably within reach of plan sponsors and fiduciaries. With that guidance now in place, EBSA is likely to be increasingly unsympathetic to plan sponsors and fiduciaries who do nothing to address network adequacy. The JAMA study gives regulators, plaintiffs’ counsel, and participants a ready-made, peer-reviewed benchmark for what “doing nothing” looks like. A plan fiduciary that can show it asked the right questions, reviewed the answers, pressed for corrective action, and documented that process is in a far better position than one that simply relied on the TPA’s directory.
Thompson Hine Takeaways: Practical Steps for Plan Sponsors and Fiduciaries
Employers cannot solve the shortage of mental health clinicians, but they can, and should, maintain a documented process for monitoring the TPAs and networks that maintain their directories.
- Review your TPA, ASO, and/or network provider agreement(s). Confirm which party is responsible for NSA directory verification and related requirements and who bears the cost when Section 720(b) requires the plan to pay a claim at in-network cost-sharing because of a directory error. Consider whether indemnification and audit rights are adequate.
- Ask how the 90-day verification actually works. Request a written description of the TPA’s verification method and frequency and its procedure and timeframe for removing unverifiable providers. Ask whether verification confirms that a provider is reachable and accepting new patients, not just that a contract exists.
- Ask for directory accuracy testing results. Ask whether the TPA conducts internal audits or secret shopper testing of mental health listings in the markets where your participants live, and request the results. Plan sponsors with sufficient resources may also consider periodically sample-testing directory listings themselves.
- Request network adequacy metrics that reflect real access. As we recommended in our September post, request and review network adequacy metrics for parity, including access standards, wait times, and geographic coverage. Ask for appointment availability and wait time data for mental health/substance use disorder providers and compare these measures with medical/surgical measures. If your TPA does conduct internal audits or secret shopper testing, ask how those results are accounted for in the network adequacy metrics and reports.
- Monitor out-of-network utilization and complaints. Request periodic reports comparing out-of-network utilization for mental health/substance use disorder and medical/surgical benefits and track participant complaints about access to in-network mental health/substance use disorder providers. Disproportionate out-of-network use or complaints can signal network problems that warrant follow-up.
- Confirm Section 720(b) is operationalized. Ask how the TPA identifies and adjusts claims where a participant relied on inaccurate directory information, how participants can raise the issue, and whether written response-protocol communications are retained as required.
- Use the tools you do control. Encourage or require your TPA to use single-case agreements and network gap exceptions for mental health/substance use disorder services on terms no more restrictive than for medical/surgical services. In addition, consider expanding mental health telehealth coverage. Although most group health plans have little control over network composition, ask what your TPA is doing to recruit and retain mental health/substance use disorder providers, and how those actions compare to medical/surgical recruitment.
- Consider seeking amendments to exclusivity clauses in TPA, or ASO, and/or network provider agreement(s). Review relevant agreements for terms, such as network exclusivity provisions, that would prevent the plan from independently contracting with mental health and substance use disorder provider groups or telemedicine providers to supplement the existing provider network. If such terms exist, consider seeking amendments that would waive application of those restrictions in the event network adequacy problems are identified, whether through an audit, an MHPAEA analysis, or otherwise.
- Address these issues in RFPs. When selecting a new TPA or network, incorporate directory accuracy and network adequacy questions, along with the MHPAEA network adequacy NQTL questions in EBSA’s compliance tool, into the RFP. Avoid exclusivity restrictions or seek to negotiate exceptions.
- Document everything. Record in committee minutes or similar records the information requested, the responses received, issues identified, corrective action requested, and outcomes. Work with counsel to determine how best to document this monitoring.
If you have questions, please contact any of the authors or your regular Thompson Hine attorney.
